There is no way to write comprehensively about a subject this big in one post, and I won’t try here. I want to just highlight a few points that have struck me forcefully this week, as the spectacle of media fawning over Jenner – whom I will call XY Jenner – unfolds before us.
The first and most basic point is that we have a body of empirical knowledge that tells us XY Jenner is a human male, and that he cannot be made female. If one day we will have the ability to manipulate DNA in such a way that that is possible, we don’t have it today.
The concepts of “gender,” and nature-vs.-nurture, are meaningful ones. But the evidence of our eyes, and the sum total of our shared knowledge, tell us that male (XY) and female (XX) correlate powerfully with “man” and “woman,” to such a pervasive extent that there is no value for our lives in tossing that assumption aside. Continue reading “Bruce/‘Caitlyn’ Jenner and the collapse of the Western mind”